I found this week’s topic of the
migrant crisis that Europe is facing very interesting and also one that the
United States is having a similar issue with. While the United States has not
taken on as many refugees as Europe, it is beginning to look into how it can
expand accepting refugees.
Specifically, in this topic of a
refugee crisis is the problem of anti-immigrant views among people in these
countries. In the reading from the Guardian, by Kate Connolly, we are informed
of a group that holds those views, Pegida. Pegida represents a growing
percentage of the population that is frustrated from Europe accepting
immigrants. “when virtually every town and community is gripped by the question
of how to house its share of the refugees that have been arriving in their
thousands every day, with no sign of a let-up”. These people are worried about
losing their identities and also their way of life. The movement has
substantially grown over the past two years, showing that this is a growing
issue.
Personally, I find the rhetoric of
groups such as Pegida hard to stand behind. What I find confusing about groups
such as these is that they often contradict themselves when speaking in public
and issuing manifestos. They say that they do not stand for hate of any kind,
while they stand on stage and say they do not want Muslims because they are all
terrorists.
But I do find myself sympathizing
with people in these countries because they are going through something that is
scary to them. People are stubborn, and often they do not accept change
gracefully. When events such as this happen and threaten to shake things up in
someone’s day to day operations, they go on the defensive. While I am not
justifying the hate speech or acts of these groups, I do believe that people do
have a right to voice their concerns. It cannot simply be said that everything
will be fine, because we do not know what will happen. But as human beings I believe
that we owe it to society to help out others when we are able to do so. While
no one wants change, if the change is to provide someone with a safe and stable
environment I think that we should be able to suck it up.
I
personally find myself torn on the issue of allowing refugees into our country.
One aspect that I tend to look at is the homeless population in the United
States. We currently have an abysmal number of men, women, and children who do
not have a stable home to live in and do not know when their next meal will
come. I believe that if we are actually going to be able to help out people
outside of our country, we must start taking care of those hear. What kind of
message does it send that the US cannot even provide steady meals for all of
its citizens, but wants to accept refugees? I believe that it does not send a
good message to those outside of the country, because it shows that we might
not be able to fully help them. But I also believe it sends a message to those
inside our country that we do not care.
Is Pegida concerned as much with the idea of these refugees being terrorists or with the idea that the government is placing these people without helping them thrive in the society? Also what is your argument. Europe is having a lot of trouble because of their human rights policies. The United States has similar standards. Are you arguing that the US should not accept these people because there is poverty within the US already? Isn't this same problem happening in Europe?
ReplyDeleteI agree with a majority of your argument, especially about United States homelessness and poverty. It definitely is a double edged sword trying to help both refugees from a war torn country and your own population. Do you think this problem of refugees would be as serious as it is if it were from a different region or people of a different religion. For example, Columbia experienced an almost 50 year Civil War that displaced many Colombians, yet it is not receiving as much attention in media. Do you think if the United States dealt with this refugee crisis the some Americans would respond as angrily as they do towards the refugee programs for Syrians?
ReplyDelete